INSULATION: Part 3 - Spray Foam

Lee Duerst • May 12, 2026

Spray Foam Insulation: High Performance — But Is It Right for Every Home?

In previous posts, we discussed fiberglass insulation and cellulose insulation. Few insulation products generate as much discussion as spray foam.

Some contractors swear by it. Some homeowners love it. Others hear the price and immediately begin clutching their wallets in fear.

So what exactly is spray foam insulation, and why has it become so popular in modern construction and energy retrofit work?

The answer comes down to one word:

Air sealing.

What Is Spray Foam Insulation?

Spray foam insulation is a material that expands after application, filling gaps, cracks, and cavities while creating an insulating layer. Unlike fiberglass or cellulose, spray foam does more than slow heat flow. It can also dramatically reduce air leakage.

That combination can make homes:

  • more comfortable,
  • more energy efficient,
  • and less drafty.

There are two primary types used in residential construction:

  • open-cell spray foam,
  • and closed-cell spray foam.

Open-Cell vs. Closed-Cell

Open-Cell Spray Foam

Open-cell foam is:

  • lighter,
  • softer,
  • and less dense.

It expands significantly during installation and is often used for:

  • wall cavities,
  • rooflines,
  • and sound reduction.

It provides insulation and air sealing but is more vapor permeable than closed-cell foam.

Closed-Cell Spray Foam

Closed-cell foam is:

  • denser,
  • more rigid,
  • and has a higher R-value per inch.

It also adds some structural rigidity and resists moisture better than open-cell foam.

Because of its high R-value and air-sealing ability, closed-cell foam is commonly used in:

  • rim joists (box sills),
  • crawl spaces,
  • basements,
  • and areas with limited space.

In cold climates like Wisconsin, closed-cell spray foam is frequently used in difficult air-leakage areas.

Why Spray Foam Performs So Well

Traditional insulation materials mainly slow conductive heat transfer.

Spray foam also attacks another major problem: Air movement.

If air can leak through cracks and gaps, heat moves with it.

That means:

  • drafts,
  • cold floors,
  • uneven temperatures,
  • and higher heating bills.

Because spray foam expands and seals openings, it can greatly reduce:

  • stack effect,
  • infiltration,
  • and hidden air leakage.

This is why many homeowners notice comfort improvements immediately after installation.

The “Tight House” Question

One of the most common concerns about spray foam is this:

“Can a house become too tight?” The short answer:
Yes — but that is not necessarily a bad thing.

Older homes often leak air everywhere:

  • attic penetrations,
  • rim joists,
  • wall cavities,
  • around windows,
  • plumbing openings,
  • and wiring holes.

That uncontrolled leakage wastes energy and can introduce moisture problems.

A tighter home is usually more efficient and comfortable. However, very tight homes may also need:

  • controlled ventilation,
  • bath fans vented properly,
  • or mechanical fresh-air systems.

Modern building science focuses on:

  • tightening the structure intentionally,
  • then ventilating it properly.

Spray Foam Is Not Cheap

Here comes the painful part.

Spray foam is usually significantly more expensive than:

  • fiberglass,
  • or cellulose.

That cost causes many homeowners to pause.

But spray foam is often used strategically rather than everywhere.

For example:

  • spray foam at box sills,
  • cellulose in the attic,
  • fiberglass in some wall cavities.

A hybrid system can balance:

  • performance,
  • budget,
  • and practicality.

Is Spray Foam Always Better?

Not necessarily.

Spray foam is an excellent product when:

  • properly installed,
  • used in the right application,
  • and integrated into the overall building system.

But every insulation material has strengths and weaknesses.

Fiberglass, cellulose, and spray foam all have situations where they work very well.

The best choice often depends on:

  • budget,
  • the structure itself,
  • moisture conditions,
  • and project goals.

Installation Quality Matters — A Lot

Spray foam is not forgiving of poor installation.

Improper mixing or application can lead to:

  • odor problems,
  • shrinking,
  • poor curing,
  • gaps,
  • or inconsistent performance.

Experience matters.

Proper ventilation during installation also matters, and homeowners may need to stay out of portions of the home temporarily during application.

Where Spray Foam Really Shines

Spray foam tends to perform best in:

  • difficult air leakage areas,
  • rim joists,
  • irregular cavities,
  • crawl spaces,
  • cathedral ceilings,
  • and areas where high R-value is needed in limited space.

It is especially effective where traditional insulation struggles to stop moving air.

So, Is Spray Foam Worth It?

For some homes, absolutely.

For others, a combination of:

  • air sealing,
  • cellulose,
  • fiberglass,
  • and targeted spray foam

may provide the best overall value.

The goal is not simply adding insulation.

The goal is creating:

  • comfort,
  • durability,
  • energy efficiency,
  • and a healthier home.

And sometimes, stopping air movement matters just as much as adding R-value.

By Lee Duerst May 15, 2026
Rex and the Case of the 47-Year-Old Furnace
By Lee Duerst May 14, 2026
Rex Discovers Why Bathroom Fans Create Problems in Attics
By Lee Duerst May 12, 2026
Cellulose Insulation: Why It Performs Differently
By Lee Duerst May 12, 2026
Fiberglass Insulation: Common, Affordable… and Often Misunderstood
By Lee Duerst April 29, 2026
The Hidden Air Leaks in Your Home
By Lee Duerst April 29, 2026
Gas Fireplaces: Convenience with Tradeoffs
By Lee Duerst April 29, 2026
Keep the Feature – Lose the Leak In previous posts, we established a few things: Fireplaces look great They’re not exactly energy all-stars And sometimes… they’re quietly working against your heating system But this isn’t a “never use your fireplace again” speech. It’s about using it smarter . Start With the Simplest Fix: Close the Damper Let’s begin with the obvious—because it’s often overlooked. Make sure the damper is fully closed when the fireplace isn’t in use Check it occasionally—it doesn’t always seal as tightly as you think A damper is better than nothing… …but it’s not an airtight solution. Think of it more like “slowing the leak” than “stopping it.” Take It a Step Further: Seal the Chimney When Not in Use If you rarely use your fireplace, this is where real improvement happens. Options include: Chimney balloons or plugs Top-sealing dampers (installed at the chimney cap) These: Block airflow more effectively Reduce heat loss significantly Help keep cold air from dropping into the house Just one rule: If you seal it—make sure you remove it before using the fireplace. (That’s a bad day otherwise.) Glass Doors: Helpful, With Limits Glass doors can: Reduce the amount of warm air pulled out of the house Improve safety (sparks, pets, kids) But they: Don’t make a fireplace “efficient” Don’t fully stop air movement Good upgrade—just don’t expect miracles. If You Use It Often, Use It Wisely For those who actually burn wood regularly: Burn dry, seasoned wood Use smaller, controlled fires Close the damper once the fire is completely out Avoid leaving it open overnight “just in case” And remember: Most traditional fireplaces still lose more heat than they produce. (Yes… even when they feel warm sitting right in front of them.) Consider an Upgrade (If It’s More Than Occasional Use) If the fireplace is part of your routine, not just a holiday guest appearance: You might look at: Fireplace inserts Sealed combustion units These: Burn more efficiently Reduce air loss Actually contribute to heating the space Now you’re moving from “ambiance” to “appliance.” Or… Rethink the Role Entirely If the fireplace isn’t used much: Seal it properly Turn it into a design feature Think: Artwork Plants Decorative logs or candles You keep the character… without the energy penalty. The Bottom Line A fireplace doesn’t have to be a problem. But left alone, it often is. The goal isn’t to get rid of it— it’s to decide what role it plays in your home. Occasional use → manage the airflow Frequent use → improve the system No use → seal it and enjoy the look Final Thought Fireplaces are great at creating atmosphere. Just don’t let them quietly heat the outdoors while you’re paying the bill. Thinking about a gas fireplace? Check out the pros and cons in this post .
By Lee Duerst April 29, 2026
Why using a fireplace can actually make your house colder.
By SEO Marketing Team April 29, 2026
How an unused fireplace quietly increases your heating bill.
By Lee Duerst April 29, 2026
🔥 If you’re not using it, your house still is.
Show More